Close

Login

Close

Register

Close

Lost Password

Book Review

Publisher's Note:

With dreams of striking it rich in the American gold rush, James McCorkle never expected to be robbed on his first day in America. But when some thugs steal literally everything he owns, this young Irishman desperately joins the United States Army, only to discover that his troop is headed to the Utah Territory to quell a suspected Mormon rebellion. Conflicted about fighting a people he has never met, James must march to Utah to fulfill his duty. But along the way, he discovers something even more valuable than gold. Reluctant Soldier, Reluctant Saint is a surprising coming-of-age tale that reminds you that God's love can be found anywhere, even in desperate situations.…

This review may contain affiliate links, which means if you make a purchase using these links, then Compass Book Ratings may earn a small commission.

Overall Book Review:

For those of you who once played with green plastic army men, Reluctant Soldier, Reluctant Saint follows the determination of a man seeking honor while it appears he has no choice but to kill the people of the “fanatical religious sect (The Mormons).” James may have entered the army as a “sissy boy,” but by the time of his honorable discharge he has grown into a man.  This book depicts real life for soldiers in the 1800s. It follows the path of Johnston’s army as well as the trail to bravery and new hope. It is an account of the tale we know well, from a military rather than an LDS perspective. Tom Roulstone’s book is directed at men and boys, although women may enjoy it as well. 


Content Analysis:

Profanity/Language: 2 second hand reports.

Violence/Gore: A man is mugged; a man is whipped; reported whipping; 5 strong verbal threats; bear attack; man supposed dead in a storm; one character jabs another with a bayonet; 2 men are imprisoned with chains.

Sex/Nudity: 3 low cut gowns; two characters dance very close together; a few kisses; two characters hold one another close; a man pays a bar maid to “do more than just dance”; a woman tries to get a man to sleep with her.  

Mature Subject Matter:

Robbery; War; Religious Conflict; Death. 

Alcohol / Drug Use:

Characters drink whiskey in one scene; two characters smoke pipes; one character chews tobacco; a woman gets drunk at a dance; army men go drinking at the local bar.

Overall Book Rating
Profanity/Language
Rating:
1
10
Violence/Gore
Rating:
3
10
Sex/Nudity
Rating:
4
10

Share This Post

About the Reviewer

Take me to a book store and it will be at least an hour before you can pry me from the shelves, never leaving empty handed. I have had my own bookcases (that’s right, plural) collecting my favorites since I was little. I like reading not only for the storyline, but also to see the author’s creativity and the way their personality comes through in their writing.