Close

Login

Close

Register

Close

Lost Password

Book Review

Publisher's Note:

Best friends Mary Lennox, Sara Crewe, and Cedric Erroll are best friends. And thank goodness, since their boarding school is basically insufferable. When one of the friends suffers a personal tragedy, a plan—and a secret—change everything for the trio . . . for good. Filled with charm and romance, and inspired by some of classic literature's most beloved characters, The Secret Princess is the perfect blend of A Little Princess and The Secret Garden—and the perfect companion to Jo & Laurie.…

This review may contain affiliate links, which means if you make a purchase using these links, then Compass Book Ratings may earn a small commission.

The Secret Princess

Melissa de la Cruz and Margaret Stohl

Overall Book Review:

A Secret Princess is the newly imagined re-telling of multiple classic stories for a new generation.  Familiar to older readers and movie goers alike, this novel likely will not feel as familiar to younger readers.  It is the combination of A Secret Garden and A Little Princess where the author has maintained similar themes and characters but has retold the story with changes to nationalities, cultural identifications, and reasonings as to their orphan status.

For the most part, the characters in this novel are as I would have expected them to be.  Sara Crewe has been changed to an English Filipino parentage and I appreciated the dimension that was added to the story as she dealt with stereotypes and racism being sent to an English finishing/boarding school.  Mary’s audacity, creativity, and ability to make the best of any circumstance instantly endeared this character to me.  I found myself cheering her on as she takes on teachers and students alike throughout the book.  Cedric’s character certainly held some surprises, but his was probably the one character that I felt was a little lacking in the end.  His was the most predictable and therefore probably the least interesting of characters.

While set in mid-century England, I did appreciate that a more modern version of English was used in the language of the book.  I think this will make it quite palatable to young readers who may have struggled more with mid-century English.  The settings are relatively well-done and readers will be able to put themselves inside the story with relative ease.  The garden scenes were possibly the most difficult, especially if you weren’t familiar with the types of plants that were being described.  Some of the awesomeness was likely lost if you aren’t familiar with the fact that those plants and animals are completely out of place in an English garden.

Overall, it was a good book.  Possibly a bit predictable for older readers familiar with the underlying stories, but a decent new mash up appropriate for younger readers.

Review of a Digital Advance Reading Copy provided by the Publisher

Profanity/Language:  5 religious exclamations; 12 mild obscenities; 2 derogatory names.

Violence/Gore:  Squeeze to arm leaving a mark; report of deaths due to natural causes or acts of nature; slap to face; backhand to back of head; report of execution by firing squad.

Sex/Nudity:  6 instances of hand-holding; 1 hug; 1 instance where female sits on male’s lap in order to dance in wheelchair; 2 instances of kiss to hands.

Mature Themes: 

Death, abandonment, racial and social inequalities, mental illness, physical disability, indentured servitude, homelessness.

Alcohol and Drug Use: 

None

Overall Book Rating
Profanity/Language
Rating:
3
10
Violence/Gore
Rating:
2
10
Sex/Nudity
Rating:
1
10

Share This Post

About the Reviewer

I am a full-time mom, full-time wife, and overtime reader. I have been an avid reader for as long as anyone can remember. It must run in the family because both my mother and grandmother are also voracious readers and often pass books back and forth. Almost any genre can spark my interest, but I often go in streaks, reading a bunch of books from one genre, then switching to another for a while and back again.